MedicinhistorieUdstillinger

Examine first, ask what it is later — comments on David Pantalony’s talk at Medical Museion

Yesterday, David Pantalony from University of Ottawa and the Canada Science and Technology Museum gave a talk in Medical Museion’s MUSE seminar series titled ‘Examine first, ask what it is later: The multiple interpretations of 20th century scientific artifacts’. David’s presentation gave rise to an intense discussion and an interesting stream of twitter-comments that are eternalised on Storify […]

Yesterday, David Pantalony from University of Ottawa and the Canada Science and Technology Museum gave a talk in Medical Museion’s MUSE seminar series titled ‘Examine first, ask what it is later: The multiple interpretations of 20th century scientific artifacts’.
David’s presentation gave rise to an intense discussion and an interesting stream of twitter-comments that are eternalised on Storify here.
Some excerpts from the Twitter comments here:

  • Engaging objects is a way of resisting a textual constriction of knowledge
  • Maybe you cld say that an ‘exhibition curator’ *cares* for objects, while an ‘exhibitionist’ shows off
  • Did Pantalony just say: “I don’t really understand exhibitions” ?
  • Bottom-up curatorship is a good example of biopolitical production (vide Negri) – after all Latin ‘cura’ means ‘care’
  • “Going into the collection my goal is to learn about the world. Not the history of specific technology” (David Pantalony)
  • Wonderful to hear a exhibition curator (@SciTechCurator) who takes the collected object as his evident point of departure
  • Collection multitude vs. cultural Empire (to paraphrase Hardt and Negri)
  • Museum collections are an “immovable foundation of diversity” in a culturally and politically homogenous landscape
  • Pantalony: Museum collections as source of diversity to counter cultural, political, artistic & intellectual homogeneity in society.
  • Medical device arrives at museum painted one color. Doesn’t mean it spent its working life in that particular skin
  • Pantalony neatly gestalts his points about the need for a close engagement with objects through his own enthusiasm.
  • Where to start when starting from a museum object? How about asking if people *like* it and why?
  • David (@SciTechCurator) radiates a unadulterated love for objects; very contagiuos 🙂
  • Pantalony persuasive on starting from the object for curation, display, and also teaching and staff encounters
  • Museum objects as trophees!
Medicinsk Museion
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.